Amazing things happened this past Sunday. The Giants beat the Patriots, a huge group of us watched The Godfather, and I made braciole. We decided to have a themed Italian evening because our friend Ali had never seen The Godfather. And obviously we decided to make a sick Italian meal, which I immediately volunteered to spearhead. I hadn’t made a decent red sauce in forever, and with the drop in temperature it was the perfect opportunity.
All last week I tried to think about what I wanted to make. I relived fond memories from Sunday nights when I was in high school, sitting down at our family table to the most epic feasts. We took The Sopranos very seriously at that time, and found ourselves eating decadent Italian meals on those Sunday nights. My sister would make a vat (I’m not exaggerating about this) of red sauce with hidden treasures floating around inside. Sausage, homemade meatballs, and braciole would float merrily for hours in a simmering sauce. By the time dinner was ready the scent danced all through our house. And it was always insanely good. It wasn’t until much later in life that I realized I was spoiled when it came to dinners with my family.
I decided I wanted to relive those fond memories. Our friends were going to contribute to the meal, so the entree was all I needed to concern myself with. I asked my sister if we used to make the braciole she added to her sauce all those years ago. She said we didn’t, but wasn’t sure where my parents got it. I realized I hadn’t eaten it since I lived at home, which is going on 7 years now. I eventually found out from my mother that not only is it sold at Shop Rite, but they have three different options to choose from! Yet another reason why the East Coast (and let’s be honest it’s really all about Jersey) trumps most other places. So it was decided. I was going to make braciole.
I found a simple yet satisfying looking recipe from Giada. I trust most of what she makes even though she puts carrots in her red sauce. I can never get behind that. But this recipe was a winner. So much so, that I have been thinking about it all week. Like after an amazing first date, I have dreamily been wondering when I would see it next again. You can find Giada’s original recipe HERE.
As previously stated, I refuse to make her sauce, and stick to my family’s recipe. Italians always have the most simple recipes that just shouldn’t taste as good as they are. I’ve never been able to understand it, but when I ask my grandmother for recipes she just rattles off only a few ingredients each time. And with that, here is how we make our red sauce:
- 2-4 cans of crushed tomatoes (in Jersey we favored Tuttoruso, but I can’t find that here so I usually go with Hunts)
- 1 small can of tomato paste
- 1 brown onion chopped
- 2-3 cloves of garlic, crushed
- fresh basil, torn
- quick pour of red wine
- sugar as needed
- salt and pepper to taste
The great thing about making a red sauce is that you really rely on your palette to make it great. It’s a lot of adding one ingredient, letting it sit, and then tasting to find out where to go next. And all the ingredients vary based on how much sauce you’re making.
To begin, heat some oil in a pot and add your chopped onion. Stir frequently and let soften a little before adding the garlic. Keep stirring so nothing browns. You just want them to get a little bit of color before adding the crushed tomatoes and paste. I often have a heavy hand with the paste, resulting in a very thick sauce, so use at your own risk. Most of the time you rarely need more than half of one of those very small cans. Mix this and bring to a boil. Watch out. Like a volcano, the sauce will get angry out of nowhere and blow up all over your stove.
Bring to a simmer and add a quick pour of red wine. This particular occasion I used a sweet Spanish red that basically sweetened the sauce enough without the addition of sugar. I usually use a cab, but feel free to use whatever you’ve got. Let that simmer for a while partially covered. Then take a taste. Make an educated decision about how much salt and pepper you’d like to add. This is usually where I add my basil as well. More simmering. More tasting. More adjusting. If you’ve got the time, the best results come from letting a pot of sauce simmer for hours. It makes for a great Sunday night meal because of just that. Every couple hours, take a taste and adjust as you see fit. I had my friends take a taste towards the end and help me adjust.
Now for the braciole:
- 1/2 c dried Italian bread crumbs
- 1 garlic clove crushed
- 2/3 c of grated Pecorino Romano
- 1/2 c of grated sharp Provolone
- 2 Tbs fresh Italian Parsley- chopped
- 4 Tbs olive oil
- salt and pepper
- 1 (1 1/2 lb) flank steak
- 1 c dry white wine
- 3 1/4 c of red sauce
Giada doesn’t have you pound the beef (a phrase I took to saying all day because sometimes I really am that immature), but I cried bull roar. So I took out my mallet and went for it. And then I had Joe New pound some meat (I’m sorry but I had to) while I got to fixing the filling because I was running WAY behind schedule. The flank I picked up was a little less that 1 1/2 lbs, but it was the last one in the store so I had to make it work. I was serving five and knew it was going to be tight.
I mixed the bread crumbs, garlic, cheese, and parsley in a bowl. It formed a really dry paste and spread that over the flattened steak. Then it’s just a simple jelly roll.
I cut a few pieces of twine and tied them around the roll to keep it in place. Then I heated some olive oil in a skillet and browned the roll on each side. I added the cup of white wine (We conveniently have a giant bag of white wine that sits in a cardboard box with a picture of a barrel on it. It IS an optical illusion as well as being borderline awful. But who am I to complain about free wine?) and then the red sauce and covered the roll in these delicious liquids. Then I tented the pan with aluminum foil and popped it into the oven, which had been preheated to 350.
Now Giada tells you to really take your time. Let this baby roast for an hour before removing the foil and keeping in the oven for another 30 min. I halved this. Like I said I was running late! So I popped it in for 30 minutes, basted, and took the foil off for another 15. It worked out well.
When it was time, I took it out and sliced it into glorious sections. We paired it with a light pasta side our friend Ali had made. It was fantastic! Hearty, but not heavy. Flavorful, but simple. Just the perfect dish. Next time I’ll definitely pair it with spaghetti. I’d also like to play around with searing it, then cutting it raw and adding it to the sauce to simmer all day. I bet that would be out of this world!